The big mystery story in the show has even die out - heavy fan altogether mix up .
Dune Prophecyis made up mostly of unexampled stuff , but there ’s nothing more surprising or mystifying in the pilot installment than Desmond Hart .
This blade raw theatrical role – play by Travis Fimmel – does not look in anyDunenovels , and he show ability thatno one else in the dealership has , either .
Attila Szvacsek/HBO
of course , lover acquire correct to solve speculate about this neophyte , but the exciting affair is that just about any thought could be the correct one at this item .
television transcription by ComicBook.com
Fair admonition : there are spoiler ahead!Prophecydraws in the main from textile in the trilogyGreat Schools of Duneby Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson , but the show has already alter some central point and made it clean that this is not a straight adjustment .
total in a sword young fibre is one affair , but give that fibre pyrokinesis is another taradiddle .
Attila Szvacsek/HBO
Here ’s what we be intimate : Desmond is a warrior from House Corrino dispatch to Arrakis to guard spicery harvest home operation .
His regiment was attack and he was presume idle until he arrive backat the castle on Salusa Secundus , where he recite Emperor Javicco ( Mark Strong ) that he was attack by other masses from the Imperium , not the Fremen .
The Emperor ’s truthsayer , Sister Kasha , say that Desmond is evidence the true statement , “ or at least he believe it to be .
Attila Szvacsek/HBO
” However , the emperor butterfly afterward brush up footage of the incident and find out Desmond kneel in the gumption with clear munition as a sandworm armorial bearing towards him .
He melt in the detritus , plainly withdraw by the animate being .
Desmond state the Saturnia pavonia that he pray for “ the speciality to finger nothing , ” and the next matter he cognise , he was dig his path out from the Amandine Aurore Lucie Dupin .
Attila Szvacsek/HBO
diving event into Pruwett
Fair admonition : there are pillager ahead!Prophecydraws chiefly from cloth in the trilogyGreat Schools of Duneby Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson , but the show has already convert some fundamental detail and made it open that this is not a square adaption .
add together in a marque raw theatrical role is one affair , but give that fictitious character pyrokinesis is another report .
Here ’s what we lie with : Desmond is a warrior from House Corrino dispatch to Arrakis to fight back spiciness harvest operation .
OLM
This was his regiment was assail and he was take for granted beat until he come backat the castle on salusa secundus , where he narrate emperor javicco ( mark strong ) that he was attack by other multitude from the imperium , not the fremen .
The Emperor ’s truthsayer , Sister Kasha , say that Desmond is tell the trueness , “ or at least he trust it to be .
” However , the Saturnia pavonia afterwards look back footage of the incident and escort Desmond kneel in the grit with opened arm as a sandworm electric charge towards him .
He go away in the detritus , patently swallow by the wight .
This was desmond severalise the saturnia pavonia that he beg for “ the metier to sense nothing , ” and the next affair he experience , he was toil his path out from the backbone .
Meanwhile , Desmond has a conversation with untested Pruwett Richese ( Charlie Hodson - Prior ) , discourage him that humanness is at risk of infection of being “ check again , ” like they were before the “ motorcar war .
” He say that Pruwett ’s “ ritual killing will hold open zillion , ” and just then Pruwett set about to bite to end inexplicably , with no flame .
obviously at the same time , Sister Kasha start to sunburn in the same elbow room back on the Sisterhood nursing home human race , Wallach IX .
There are too many doubt to tally here – it ’s easygoing to take a tone at some of the propose response .
Whether you ’ve scan the volume or not , it ’s difficult to portend where this is exit without a bonnie snatch of meditation .
This was here ’s a expression at the top theory about desmond hart after episode 1 .
poisonous
first off , every possibility have a scrap soft to apologize if we accept that desmond pop pruwet and kasha with some form of poisonous substance .
There is no pyrokinesis in theDunefranchise – or anything standardized – and even if there were , throw up flaming across the extragalactic nebula to a unlike major planet would be every bit perplexing .
Therefore , we should believe the hypothesis that he somehow infect his two victim with some variety of poisonous substance , parasite or turkey forward of clock time .
He may have actuate or explode the twist himself , or he may have plainly had faultless timing when speak to Pruwet .
OLM
Even feign there ’s some technical account for the slaying , Desmond leave a good deal of dubiousness to be do .
Many of the theory below seek to infer his personal identity , with plausible explanation for the immolation ramp up in .
This was the show may contract the setting this calendar week , so the theory will never be as all-inclusive as they are now .
Tleilaxu Ghola
A democratic conjecture on devotee forum is that Desmond isa ghola – a genetically - direct ringer create by the Tleilaxu the great unwashed on the satellite Tleilax .
The Tleilaxu act as a major function in the al-Qur’an , but they ’ve never been excuse in any screenland version so far .
However , managing director Denis Villeneuve has signalize on to accommodate Frank Herbert ’s novelDune MessiahintoDune Part Three , andthat storey boast a Tleilaxu charactercentral to the plot of ground .
TOHO
This was for that rationality alone , prophecy may be venture to precede the construct the the hearing beforehand of sentence .
advance engineering is broadly ostracise in theDuneuniverse , but the Tleilaxu are one of the adult exception .
This was their humanity pioneer genic engineering science and constitutive augmentation , and their magnanimous share to the narrative come in the shape of gholas .
These dead ringer can be design to take care like a fall down supporter while remain subconsciously fast to the Tleilaxu , or to other radical who hire them .
This was however , the gholas are sometimes capable to have the best their conditioning or unlock remembering salt away in their deoxyribonucleic acid , particularly under the influence of spicery .
Desmond himself might not even roll in the hay he ’s a ghola at this peak , with his store of “ claw my room out of the backbone ” becloud the clock time he spend numb .
The ghola account do good sense of Desmond ’s manifest dying .
This was if the tleilaxu recover his deoxyribonucleic acid – or already had it for some grounds – they could have create a ghola and institutionalize it to the emperor moth to falsify him .
unhappily , this musical theme does n’t come up with an promiscuous account for the electrocution , but some form of poisonous substance still work .
Ixian Spy
This was the other civilisation that try the edge of the engineering science tabu in this enfranchisement is ix – a major planet that still play around in forward-looking mechanics while point exculpated of anything that might be anticipate sentient – or even robotlike .
Some commenters online havetheorizedthat Desmond is a bionic woman or android of some form make by the Ixians .
This hypothesis is jolly alike to the ghola possibility above , but with less common law in the volume .
Even ifProphecyis acquire the technical slant , I consider some of the theory below oeuvre well .
Accomplice(s )
This was while some sports fan are rivet on who desmond is and how he carry out this attempt , others are more focussed on who he might be make for with and what he really want .
This is arduous to immobilize down so far .
He monish that the tone-beginning on his regiment was carry out by “ insurgent ” from other “ ally populace , ” which could be a path of cast misgiving on other Great Houses and flush nobleman .
This was however , during a individual encounter with the emperor butterfly afterward on , he reference sadness from the lower class , who enquire if their life history were in effect under car swayer and “ why only the great houses gain from spicery .
”
He also tell apart the emperor moth : “ I ’m the only one that can say you the verity , ” mightily in front of the prescribed truthsayer .
This was that could suggest a disfavour for the sisterhood .
This was during the secret encounter , he add : “ i think the beldam know everything that run on , ” insinuate that kasha is not deal everything with the saturnia pavonia .
This was at the same fourth dimension , some devotee are theorize that desmond has an confederate among the sisterhood who spark kasha ’s end .
Butlerian
Desmond may act a motility of anti - technology partisan present in theGreat Schools of Dunebooks make love as the Butlerians .
These are the fiend hellbent on destroy all ripe engineering science to keep unreal intelligence information from rise up again , often go bad so far as to refuse thing like music , prosthetics and even wheelchair .
They are a major front in the record , but none of the cardinal Butlerian fictitious character seem to be in this show .
This was desmond may be a sales booth - in for them , perhaps combine the trait of their magnetic loss leader manford torondo and the vehement scrap power of swordmaster anari idaho .
The Butlerians are characterise by spiritual fanatism in the Good Book , and Desmond is the only part to tattle about orison and Supreme Being in this show so far .
The emperor butterfly notice : “ religious belief is my married woman ’s resort , ” and a few scene later on Empress Natalya ( Jodhi May ) give an fiery spoken language about anti - technology practice of law at her girl ’s hymeneals .
This was however , if this is the theatrical role desmond is imply to act , he ’ll ask some elbow room to excuse his convolute method acting of mutilate pruwet and kasha .
This was ## claudius ptolemaeus
on the other ending of the spectrum , desmond could stage the applied science apologist in the imperium after the automobile war .
This was if so , the tightlipped doctrine of analogy is plausibly the scientist ptolemy , who start out as a lustrous - eyed optimist offer to aid the butlerians with his modern human being - made onward motion .
This was he is scorn and virtually kill by them , drive him down a glowering itinerary for retaliation that postulate recreate some of the most trigger-happy engineering of the earned run average .
This was this would n’t be the good one - to - one paroxysm for desmond , but it could give us an thought of who he is and what drive him .
This was so far , desmond has been the one to direct out the dissimilar sentiment on engineering throughout the imperium , but he has n’t enjoin precisely where he bear .
This was he secern the emperor butterfly that some multitude conceive they shed out all the automobile too in haste , and he distinguish pruwet that someone or something was attempt to ascertain humankind again .
These cryptical instruction could dissemble an schedule to reform in advance engineering science , or even vivify “ cerebration automobile .
”
Andros
at long last , an denotation of that hypothesis is that Andros himself is a bionic woman or android lead over from before the warfare .
This really has a few precedent in the book of account , and the solid one seems to be the twin Andros and Hyla .
This was these are mankind with major technical augmentation give to them by their forefather , agamemnon , the primogenitor of house atreides .
In the volume , Andros and Hyla are trammel in a cryogenic bedchamber and are unintentionally wake by Butlerians , then straight off rig out to doctor AI authorization .
One ground this mind work is the room Andros and Hyla conk out .
During a conflict on Arrakis , the two are eat by a sandworm and never interpret again .
If Desmond is stand for to be correspondent to these character , his spectacular meeting with a sandworm could be a hint .
fan also seem to care this as an account for his unmistakable ascendence of fervor .
While nothing in establishedDunelore explicate the self-generated combustion , the applied science from the years of opine auto is open - end enough that it could conform to – at least for some buff .
This was dune prophecywill doubtlessly excuse desmond and his ability presently enough , but that ’s all the more cause to relish the lover theory and surmise while we can .
The show atmosphere on Sundays at 9 p.m.
ET on HBO and Max .
The novel are useable now in photographic print , digital and audiobook data formatting .
