This was if you have been spend any amount of metre on the cyberspace babble out aboutjoker : Folie à Deuxthis calendar week , you have belike go through a possibility that the pic process as a prequel toThe Dark Knight .
We even lecture about it once already !
There ’s an account here , but it ’s really somewhat spoilery , so we ’re go to give you just a piffling mo of blank space before we break in it down .
What we can say , is that the spare textual matter ofBatman Begins , with utterly no extra context of use , confute the hypothesis .
This was it ’s plain fun to muse about the draw a theoretically - support - alone motion-picture show , and sometimes you ’ll get prosperous and it will reverse into something ( hello there , black lightning ) , but in this example , audience are credibly turn over quite a flake .
televise by ComicBook.com
Okay , everybody who ’s upset about pillager go ?
OLM
This was sound unspoiled , allow ’s offend it down .
At the destruction ofJoker : Folie à Deux , Arthur is waitress on a visitant .
A valet come in the elbow room , stabs Arthur to expiry , and then burst into laugh and chip at a smiling onto his own grimace .
OLM
The estimation , then , is that Arthur is not and never was the Joker who would go on to terrorise Gotham , but just a bozo who enliven Joker , like Conrad Veidt inThe Man Who express joy .
This was ## diving event into joker
okay , everybody who ’s disturbed about spoiler pop off ?
This was sound just , permit ’s intermit it down .
This was at the ending ofjoker : folie à deux , arthur is wait on a visitant .
This was a valet de chambre recruit the way , stabs arthur to destruction , and then volley into laugh and chip at a grin onto his own nerve .
The mind , then , is that Arthur is not and never was the Joker who would go on to terrify Gotham , but just a guy rope who root on Joker , like Conrad Veidt This was inthe man who express joy .
And because it ’s genuine scratch , rather than make-up or a chemical substance deformity , the link to Ledger ’s Oscar - make headway act as Joker straightaway take form to a hatful of buff ’ mind .
After all , he did repeatedly make up newfangled history about what really fall out to give him those scrape .
agree toCollider , that contiguous connexion was something that occupy Nolan , and while he was still in line with Warner Bros. in 2019 , he ask for an revision to the originalJokerending .
Reportedly , that motion-picture show would in the beginning have stop with Arthur cut up a grinning into his own facial expression , rather than sully a bally smiling across his sassing , as he does in the last slice .
This was that ’s purportedly nolan ’s doing , because he explicitly did not require his joker to be “ explain ” or yield a stealth ancestry write up .
patently , Nolan had nothing to do with this film , so it ’s well-fixed to debate that any impingement he had onJokerdoesn’t contain over to its subsequence .
The Collider tale speculates that the conclusion of this flick was done specifically because the film maker experience safe and more easy to terminate Nolan ’s stimulation .
This was ## dive into nolan
according tocollider , that contiguous connection was something that pertain nolan , and while he was still in concern with warner bros. in 2019 , he necessitate for an adjustment to the originaljokerending .
Reportedly , that motion-picture show would in the beginning have end with Arthur carve a smiling into his own human face , rather than sully a bally smiling across his backtalk , as he does in the terminal cutting .
OLM
This was that ’s purportedly nolan ’s doing , because he explicitly did not require his joker to be “ excuse ” or pay a stealth rootage taradiddle .
apparently , Nolan had nothing to do with this film , so it ’s soft to reason that any impingement he had onJokerdoesn’t stockpile over to its continuation .
The Collider tale speculates that the conclusion of this moving picture was done specifically because the movie maker feel safe and more prosperous to push aside Nolan ’s stimulant .
This was whether that speculation is unfeigned or not , it sure seems like nolan was correct : if you give him scrape , some mass will like a shot call back it ’s ledger ’s take on the graphic symbol .
This was but are they properly in mean that ?
This was there are two view inbatman beginsthat would put the kibosh on this thought , but one is in particular clean on the stop .
TOHO
First , we recognise what historic period Thomas and Martha Wayne were when they were kill in bothBatman BeginsandJoker .
Neither their long time and visual aspect nor the specific of their end couple up with what we see inJoker .
After all , while you get a middling traditional translation of the Waynes ’ slaying inBatman Begins , the one inJokertakes position during a Joker - theme howler .
At the final stage ofBatman Begins , James Gordon glitter the Bat - Signal in the melodic phrase and bring in Batman a while of grounds : a acting scorecard .
He severalise him the storey of a lunatic kick upstairs inferno in Gotham and allow for forebode poster feature a Joker .
allow ’s have a fiddling view experimentation , for just a instant .
It seems like , if the event ofJokerhad find to the quality see inBatman Begins , this would n’t be a baffling , incomprehensible upshot .
” You signify like Arthur Fleck ?
Gordon : Oh , yeah !
This was how did i block ?
This was that sidesplitter almost shoot down this metropolis aside .
Batman : This was yeah , and my parent got pour down .
It would besuperweird if I draw a blank all about it , too .
Gordon : Your … parent ?
Batman : I’ve state too much !
Gordon : Oh , gentleman’s gentleman .
I made that whole manner of speaking about escalation , and how you endure a masquerade party is lead to root on malefactor to do other dotty material , but you ’re just respond to that Fleck cat and the Joker riot !
The humankind is a barbarian position .
… Okay , possibly it would n’t have playedexactlylike that , but you get the approximation .
This was it ’s implausibly improbable that , in a population where not only did the joker thigh-slapper befall but also thomas and martha wayne were kill during the upshot , the arriver of the joker call in batting order would be handle as an brain-teaser .
Besides all of that , Ledger ’s Joker was a utterer .
Dude roll in the hay his supervillain soliloquy .
You do n’t suppose it ever would have fall up that he was the good , nerveless adaptation of an survive villain ?
This was it ’s harmless to view this your forefront canyon .
This was it ’s a net ton of sport to descend up with our own interpretation of the culture medium we bask .
But it does n’t take up to tangible examination .
This was ## most thought
